Catalyst - 4:45 pm on Sep 28, 2012 (gmt 0)
Sounds like you are saying Google is only showing a 3 pack of local listings?
No way you can change that. It's algo based and I assume dependent on search volume and local inventory.
Kinda surprised you would pit 5 clients against each other in the same market for the same keyword. In local SEO most consultants I know offer an exclusive so their clients aren't competing with each other.