Actually someone on this board got in touch with me. He was kind enough to examine the situation, but it was never resolved, so yesterday I sent an email to spamcrusader to try to get whatever is on my index lifted. I have very little hope in resolution, but I have to try.
You're splitting hairs. My other pages (free and the PFI one I swapped for the index page) are coming up in the first and second page of results. Whatever penalty that is on my index exists but it is not affecting the other pages. So even if the index page was in searches (the only way I could see it was to type originalurl:www.widget.html) if it's on the last page of 1,000,000 pages, there's obviously something wrong.