| 4:37 pm on Oct 25, 2013 (gmt 0)|
So Adsense revenues are dropping because of too many spam sites or because advertisers are being forced into mobile, and mobile ads do not pay as well? Nothing about the new ad formats causing a decrease in CTR.
The article also has a quote about digital publishing going over a cliff. Soon everything will be mobile and ad revenues will keep decreasing.
So is the end of the advertising supported publisher model in sight? Will Google give up on Adsense?
| 4:43 pm on Oct 25, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Do you really think Google shares have hit a recent all time high because they are stupid? Google have some very clever people working for them and along side them. The new ad format is bang on for the saying in trading lanquage of "Follow the money".
| 5:42 pm on Oct 25, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|Google have some very clever people working for them and along side them. |
I also have some very clever people working for myself yet some of them also happen to lack hardly any commonsense, rationale nor understanding when trying to work with clients.
Don't equate supposed qualifications with the simple comprehension of how business actually works in the real world when they're locked away all day in The Plex's playpens.
There were quite a few supposed "brilliant" people about in 2008 when they nearly destroyed the entire world economy.
| 11:57 pm on Oct 25, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|Nothing about the new ad formats causing a decrease in CTR. |
Yes! It's what's not being said that matters.
| 12:57 am on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Terrible today, worse than yesterday.
| 1:32 am on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
G just wiped out my custom dashboards in Analytics which were Adsense related and replaced them with their own custom dashboard which I'm sure is what they want me to focus on. Sorry, otherwise off topic but the changes keep rolling in and nothing over there is very much fun anymore.
| 1:39 am on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Good month here.
Switched from normal vertical text ads to the bigger vertical (160x600), we'll see how that goes.
Worried about mobile getting bigger... better CTR, but as others note, lower CPC in the long term?
| 1:45 am on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|G just wiped out my custom dashboards in Analytics which were Adsense related and replaced them with their own custom dashboard which I'm sure is what they want me to focus on. Sorry, otherwise off topic but the changes keep rolling in and nothing over there is very much fun anymore. |
OK, disregard. Wrong profile. :-[
| 12:10 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Redbar, there is no such thing as common sense, common sense is only in the hands of the beholder judging what common sense should be. Common sense to me would be to follow the money in what is happening in 2013. Common sense IMO also tells me that people should not attack their employer when using ads on their sites that their employer have delivered. Once any person have received a payment from Google, then technically Google become that persons employer, when Google see threads like "Haunting tales of adsense that would spook any webmaster" maybe they don't take to kindly to it and get information and then take action. I had to take serious action from this thread because Play_Bach but me into serious concern and had to straighten this out with Google that I was the innocent party on this forum and brought no Malice but just opinions of going forward with my employer. People have mentioned that this thread is quiet, are the moderators surprised? people like myself get attacked once joining the forum and many many people read this thread believe me! people are scared of getting attacked on this forum from the clique. The clique soon could get delt with IMO. I am very Pro Google and actaually want to work with people that common sense tells me IMO that they are clever and moving things forward. If any one thinks Google are not clever then why don't you get out of their programme? If people stand still and expect the earnimgs they experienced many years ago then they deserve everything they get, times move, move with them like the plex is moving it.
People can hit me with any comment they like I am thick skinned, what I can't stand is people like Play_bach reporting me to Google when the facts are wrong, if you are in this forum clique and your earnings take a dive then YOU only have yourself to blame for joining a right wing forum against Google.
| 1:21 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
There have been "haunting tales of AdSense that would spook any webmaster" as long as this forum has been around; Google barely comes here any more, and even if they do, they don't act against webmasters on the basis of forum posts. If that were the case, I wouldn't be doing better every single year with AdSense, because I am not shy about laying into them on forums, on my website and on Twitter, and they *know* who I am.
But what you *don't* do is waltz into an existing forum like you own the place and tell all the members (some of whom have been posting here for almost ten years, and participating in AdSense since it opened its doors) that you're going to school us all in the finer points of AdSense. We'll put up with it for a while, but if you make yourself unwelcome, we will most definitely let you know. Repeatedly.
If you're expecting true anonymity and privacy online, get over it. It's 2013.
If you're worried about being kicked out of AdSense because of forum participation, then maybe you should rethink your decision to participate. We'll manage; it'll be difficult, but I think we'll pull through.
Meanwhile, this post is about October Earnings and Observations, and let's get back to that.
I'm doing almost exactly the same as last year this month, oddly, even the CTR is the same. It's so similar it's weird. Fortunately since the rest of the year was so much better, I'm still way up. But I'm uneasy about where AdSense may be going (re that article); I will definitely be spending more time on direct ad sales. Built a way cool signup form with WordPress and Gravity Forms!
| 1:33 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Really? I hadn't noticed that at all!
Just why do you obviously consider Google employees to be so much more clever than everyone else on the planet? I can tell you that Google are being run ragged by blackhatters, there are some extremely intelligent and smart people out there that are running rings around Google and not only do they know it they seemingly powerless to do anything about it.
|yourself to blame for joining a right wing forum against Google. |
From where on earth do you get your comparisons? A right wing group would be happy to work with Google since they'd all be in the money!
If anything it should be a left wing group since many webmasters and sites consider that they are being exploited, under-valued and under-paid.
There is no forum clique here, I've been here under several guises for more than 10 years and had many a discussion with the best in the industry. Without doubt there has been a massive amount of frustration with Google this past 2-3 years with them implementing so many changes mostly, it would seem, only for their own benefit and not their so-called "partners" and their continued non-willingness for discourse with this, or any other, forum board.
Fine, it's their business therefore if they want to run it without any input from their so-called "partners" then they ought not to be surprised when things start to go wrong and none of us turn around to assist. I did that for them in the 90s, for free, I ain't doing it again!
| 3:31 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Back on subject. Just passed last months Adsense earnings with few more days to go. Non adsense earnings are way up, adsense earnings slightly up.
Direct ad sales and affiliate are now about 50% of revenue. At one time Adsense was 95% of revenue.
These days you need more than one basket for your eggs.
| 7:48 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Oddly my EPC took a huge dip for the period Oct 18-22, and then came back better than ever. No idea what happened for those five days, nor why it came back.
| 8:39 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|Oddly my EPC took a huge dip for the period Oct 18-22, and then came back better than ever. No idea what happened for those five days, nor why it came back. |
This has happened to me the last two months, only it's been the first week that has taken a big dive. Just when I start to panic, it's come back better than before. No idea why.
| 9:15 pm on Oct 26, 2013 (gmt 0)|
My pattern lately seems to be bad day > good day > bad day > good day > etc.
I'm kind of beginning to think the good days include clicks from the day before because the overall (month) average is fairly stable at recent levels.
| 2:08 am on Oct 27, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Oct 3rd/4th dramatic 50% drop. Gradual build since then but still 20% off.
| 9:07 pm on Oct 27, 2013 (gmt 0)|
I hope this DST change is the culprit for such a low eCPM this week-end...
| 11:25 pm on Oct 27, 2013 (gmt 0)|
We don't change till next week. But yea, EPC crashed again today. Fortunately I'm already at 97% of last October, so barring unforeseen circumstances, I should beat it.
| 4:05 pm on Oct 28, 2013 (gmt 0)|
It's been terrible since oct24 if I recall correctly, suddenly a solid 50% of my daily earnings.
| 12:39 am on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
RPM for the past week have been highest week for october for me.
Earning is roughly in the same range as my pv's have been lower for seasonal and trending reasons.
Don't see much variations with CTR.
| 5:50 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Can we assume that all these observations are made from sites with reasonably high and constant traffic levels?
E.G. At least 1000+ uniques per day. I would have thought anything lower than this would naturally be unstable….. ?
| 7:43 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|E.G. At least 1000+ uniques per day. I would have thought anything lower than this would naturally be unstable….. ? |
I don't know how specific we can go here in WebmasterWorld. Not all my sites run Adsense for personal reasons and several other ones... but I'm having about 5K uniques daily and earnings went down to 50%. The traffic is all organic, stable, no paid links, everything natural, pure white hat, etc. Several years around.
| 8:40 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
MY CTR keeps on decreasing and It's getting totally out of control. My RPM is at 20% of what it used to be before Sept 19th (first huge drop on Sept 19th after redesigned ads have launched, then Oct 4-5th, and it keeps on decreasing).
I've been having adsense on my sites for years and never seen this so bad. I think Google is shaving us big time - things cannot keep on dropping this dramatically without any changes on our end.
| 8:54 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
What I have is a group of sites in the same vertical, the observation I make is based on the gross total of pv's and earnings.
My sites with 2~5k pv's all flucuate between 50%~200% of average earning. An expensive click is all it takes to throw it over the average. But once you add all of them together, they soften the edges of each other. And I now have a consistent earning +/- 10% of the average.
Is that something that other people see as well?
| 8:57 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
All of my metrics have gone exponential today. CPC up from around an average of .28 cents to over $2 today. Revenue about 5X what it normally is. I have no idea why. Anybody else?
Maybe an adjustment in the SERPs, my PR hasn't changed, maybe I just got a couple of $10 clicks or something. Not complaining, actually rather pleased, but I'll bet my estimated earnings will vary widely from my finalized earnings this month. Took a 15% hit last month, not too happy about that.
| 10:12 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
I don't think Google is shaving us (my own experience is directly the opposite, and something like that would get out, as they are reporting a specific share percentage in each and every one of our accounts) but the entire advertising landscape has significantly changed in recent years. The way AdWords works has changed ginormously, ad blindness, mobile, ad blocking technology, ad styles, you name it. It's a different ballgame.
| 11:45 pm on Oct 29, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Love the drama injected into the daily reports thread. Just finished my bowl of popcorn.
Today, my earnings are steamy. As I like to say, hot and juicy. The month has been stellar, but even with a lower traffic situation today, my earnings are going higher and faster than I have typically seen lately.
| 2:04 am on Oct 30, 2013 (gmt 0)|
According to my google adsense app I'm up 16% This month so far vs same day Last month.
| 2:08 am on Oct 30, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Publisher and Websites quality.
There was a comment a while ago regarding Adsense having more and more websites of low quality, some took offense on it, not me. I somehow agree with the statement because MFAs are all around still to this day.
But not only that... take a look at the many low quality, off topic and unrelated posts on this branch, it clearly reflects some of that original statement. A lot of webmasters have complained online and by PM and many others just left (and some are still leaving) part of this is, as some member said: there is little to analyze (at least easily) because GAdsense is like rolling the dice. There are still very good posts but in my opinion there is increasing noise in the forum. Old are the days were reading was about post by post, now I reach the end of the page more often.
| 5:36 am on Oct 30, 2013 (gmt 0)|
|Can we assume that all these observations are made from sites with reasonably high and constant traffic levels? |
You know what they say about "assumptions," right? It's amazing that anyone feels they can glean any useful information from posts that read "Revenue up 50% today" or "Today was my worst day ever."
Try these assumptions on for size
Everyone posting here uses Adsense text ads exclusively (as opposed to mixing it up with display ads).
Everyone positions ads in the same place on their pages e.g. always a Leaderboard above the fold.
or, here's a good one...
Everybody in this thread targets the same niche and the same geographic audience.
Assume away! Numbers without any context are just numbers!
| 9:45 am on Oct 30, 2013 (gmt 0)|
Good points, webcentric, but I have made no assumptions about anything concerning Tuesday being the best day I've had for revenue in about three years (The all-time record the result of a certain person dying, and me having a huge traffic surge due to an article I had written about this person.)
So, humor me a moment, and allow me to dissect my own huge earnings day.
As usual, with any unforeseen event, we try to put causation into the equation, and I am postulating that my big day had to do with a confluence of factors.
1. Recent success in one area which generated targeted traffic.
2. End of month ad spending
3. Increased effort to drive traffic from another source.
4. Luck, fate, karma, other uncontrollable forces.
These are nothing more than guesses, however. Adsense continues to be extremely opaque - like government or the tooth fairy. In the case of government, we don't actually know exactly why it DOESN'T WORK so well, as in the ObamaCare website, yet we can count on it to be highly dysfunctional in many enterprises.
The tooth fairy may be a better metaphor for Adsense. We put the teeth under the pillows (implement the ad code on our sites) and the tooth fairy (Googlebot) delivers money. We never know how much money and there is usually no causal relationship (bigger teeth or multiple teeth don't necessarily generate more income). The money just shows up.
Just my two cents. In any case, the days prior to and following record-setting days are always somewhat disappointing. Such is the way of the Google tooth fairy. Kinda like the stock market, too.
Edit: this post brought up recollections of the work of a stock market favorite, Nassim Nicholas Taleb, who wrote "Fooled by Randomness" and "The Black Swan." Other authors have written extensively on the subject, citing dumb luck and "being in the right place at the right time," usually by accident, as outsize factors in investing success.