http://www.webmasterworld.com Welcome to WebmasterWorld Guest from 38.103.63.17
register, login, search, glossary, subscribe, help, library, PubCon, announcements , recent posts, unanswered posts
Accredited PayPal World Seller
Home / Forums Index / The Google World / Google Search News
Forum Library : Charter : Moderators: Robert Charlton & lawman & mack & tedster

Google Search News

  
Google Trends - how accurate is it? Part 2
Whitey


#:3624422
 10:48 am on April 11, 2008 (utc 0)

Last year I raised a concern about Google Trends accuracy for those using it as a reliable tool : http://www.webmasterworld.com/google/3422371.htm

8 months or so later I went back in to compare the trend on a No1 position we've held for the last 6 months and compared trends taken from our log statistics to the Google Trend.

The Google Trend graphically indicates a sharp fall from January through to the end of March. But our log files show relative consistency. On the basis of this, i don't even find it indicative.

Anyone else ?

trinorthlighting


#:3624698
 4:29 pm on April 11, 2008 (utc 0)

Are you pulling your log files and looking at Google queries only? Or are your log files dumping in MSN and Yahoo queries?

Whitey


#:3624944
 9:14 pm on April 11, 2008 (utc 0)

These results are seperated Google from Yahoo and MSN . Yahoo and MSN account for little more than 5% of our SE traffic.

trinorthlighting


#:3626381
 1:04 pm on April 14, 2008 (utc 0)

I do notice differences in trends versus the adwords keyword tools.

The adwords tools look like they are up to date.

https://adwords.google.com/select/KeywordToolExternal

Miamacs


#:3626470
 2:54 pm on April 14, 2008 (utc 0)

AdWords shows you logarithmic stuff... that search volume bar is nowhere near linear, plus the volume it represents is just as dynamically 'interpreted' as the graph in Trends. Meaning it's relative to the rest of the keywords on your list.

Mind you Trends is linear, it just clips off stuff at the bottom ( mainly for commercial phrases ). The difference between keywords on the graph is logarithmic however.

...

my advice is use as many tools as you can, and do cross-examinations. a single tool can be wrong... two tools can still be wrong, but 4 to 5 independent tools will give you an idea at least.

Other issues include that Trends will show you the volumes for all queries made that included the set words, phrase. Using quotes will make it at least somewhere between phrase and exact match, but it's unlikely that you'd be able to get stats for a single, stand-alone phrase.

So when more and more people are satisfied with the results their first, generic search shows them...

...let's say, 'blue widget'

...they are less and less likely go into refining searches, right ?

'blue widget mycity'
'blue widhet review' ...etc.

Meaning exactly what you see: lower volumes showing in Trends and higher trtaffic volume coming from the top tier keywords. ( fewer times the phrase was used in searches... but more and more people coming from Google )

just one of the possibilities though.

...

 

Home / Forums Index / The Google World / Google Search News
All trademarks and copyrights held by respective owners. Member comments are owned by the poster.
Terms of Service ¦ Privacy Policy ¦ Report Problem ¦ About
WebmasterWorld ® and PubCon ® are a Registered Trademarks of WebmasterWorld Inc.
© WebmasterWorld Inc. / SearchEngineWorld 1996-2008 all rights reserved