I run many content sites and have had horrible luck with various related affiliates in CJ. Oddly enough, the only luck i've had a few sales was through a high end resort where you'd think you'd never get a sale. Would anyone be willing to suggest some CJ affiliates that tend to convert well on unrelated sites? I've tried the ones that seemed to make sense to me but just can't seem to find the right ones. A sticky is fine if you don't to put the info out publically.
CJ isn't the only network and there are also a ton of nice, niche affiliate programs running indie (idependent) affiliate programs. If the CJ merchants aren't converting, try something from outside that network.