| 6:55 pm on Feb 16, 2005 (gmt 0)|
I think the mother question is one that every webmaster needs to ask themselves whether it is one they care about. Most adult sites would probably fail that question, but they monetize the content very well. Some people will see that as a good reason to have a site they are not proud of OR will show to their mom.
| 10:51 pm on Feb 16, 2005 (gmt 0)|
5. Is it accurate?
6. Is it libellous?
I'm not so sure about number 4 though, it's best not to think about that if you're writing about sex or romance.
| 1:38 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
you are right on brother...
the site/page is for the end user, not for whatever we can imagine them wanting..
| 2:45 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
Livenomadic, I certainly agree with 1, 2, and 3 - and to that I would add easy-to-use, intuitive navigation.
Having quick and easy access to all that quality content is equally important.
<added>If 'moms' are your target market, then I would certainly value her input as well</added>
| 7:26 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
New information - well I scraped the serps this morning, does that count as new?
ENOUGH CONTENT - I did scrape the top 20 postions in the serps
USEFUL to a visitor - I assume it is useful since it has a 50% conversion rate. 1 out of 2 users are so happy they actually give me money.
show it to my mother - I make alot of money and can support myself, which makes my mom proud. Of course she still doesn't believe what I do is a real job since it is not in an office.
do i pass the test?
| 7:28 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
7. will it make me any money?
| 7:37 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
The two sites I'm most proud of (both sites take some effort and are unique on the web) don't make any money. They're not monetizable because they're both on extremely niche topics that no one cares about and are on reaaaaaaally boring topics. Thus no traffic.
I make money from sites that contain content and functionality that is available all over the web (well, I do think my product is a bit better than others, but still).
Your sentiment is noble, But if it doesn't make money it's a hobby. And that doesn't mean that its primary function is the author being proud or it being unique on the web or my mom looking at it.
You might better ask yourself:
1) can I drive traffic to the site?
2) can I convert/monetize the traffic?
Those are the fundamentals of what most of us are doing here, not does my mom like my web page. My mom would be bored stiff looking at one of my sites.
| 7:48 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
About question #4...
If someone pays you premium pricing, and they want the site the way THEY want it (currently a problem with a client of mine), am I not ethically to give them the page they ask for? They have 1 page so far. Index.html, and they are already up to a $3,500 bill because I've done 7 index pages, which were all completely different, and ALL specified by the CLIENT as to what THEY want. I have also created 3 'spec' index pages to give them examples of what is good & bad according to the majority of surfers & web-masters. I am not allowed any creativity, or even input in a lot of cases. So am I proud of the site? No. It's ugly, doesn't flow well, and is not completely compatible with all browsers & resolutions.
You say to redesign the page, but I CAN'T. lol Should I just turn down the money and walk away, or bite the bullet and exclude it from my portfolio? I started a thread on it Here [webmasterworld.com]
In short I am pretty sure my mother would hate it, as she is most likely using IE 4.0 at 600X800 and has bad eye sight, thus won't be able to read the non-contrating background. What ever shall I do..? I won't ever show it to her, that's what! ;0)
| 9:00 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
|7. will it make me any money? |
I hope that was meant with a bit of a ;)
| 9:06 pm on Feb 21, 2005 (gmt 0)|
>> I hope that was meant with a bit of a ;)
no, not really
| 10:40 am on Feb 22, 2005 (gmt 0)|
I think that it is the desire to earn easy money with websites, that makes them poor quality...
Obviously that is not true in every case, but 'made for adsense' sites and similar are invariably poor quality...
Of course, you will almost certainly make more money from a better quality site, but not everyone is talented or willing enough to make a great site... some people just want to make money and don't care about the site itself.
| 10:42 am on Feb 22, 2005 (gmt 0)|
I am also a bit more willing to forgive a poor quality site that is not built to make money.
(I am primarily talking about 'hobby' sites here)