|Freshness and size won't happen overnight. With billions of pages to be spidered it will take many months and some heavy server load. But it has to be done. |
Brad, AV's competition crawl the entire web at least once a month. If they wish to become a top choice SE again they will have to revisit their sites more often. I see many more Googlebots and FAST crawlers in my log files than I see Scooters.
|I submitted only 5 pages of a new site yesturday. It got it about 70 % crawled overnight....Any similar experiences of new sites not included yet? |
Macguru, I didn't even submit my new site; I only added a link to it from another site. It is a small site but I was surprised to see that Scooter had covered it already.
They should redesign the interface every week...that will get them a couple hundred visitors each time...
But seriously, there are a LOT of improvements, but they are going nowhere. If they want to be serious, they need to hire some TOPNOTCH people, get the best out of them, and determine to be the BEST bar none...they have to come out internally and say, we need to analyze every single dam thing google is doing and do it as well or better and find some innovations and do that better too.
But that is the attitude of the leader, google. AV still doesn't come close... I once emailed the CTO of AV just before google took over the search engine market, and he emailed me back that they were planning a lot of new stuff and it was going to be really great. Seemed like a nice bloke.. really too bad it didn't work out.
At the time, the idea of a portal seemed great, because Yahoo was so successful at it, and AV owned the nondirectory search... it seemed that AV really lost out in not building my.av.com. But again, their portal never touched the quality of my.yahoo.com. (And now there actually is a huge opening for a great my.something.com because yahoo's ads are killing their customer satisfaction.. and the founders of iwon.com are trying to build it, but they are also far from their goal..)
AV's idea of an icon within the results, had it been done a tad differently, could have brought them some income in a smart way and some traffic.
I have a question, if google allowed you guys to pay $1.00/month for a little icon next to your listing, with no effect on the results, and it was real subtle...how many urls would you pay that $1 on? And would it bother you as a searcher if it was there.
AV, with no traffic, is charging $19 per URL! If it were per domain, plus $x for url, ok...but $19 per url? No way...
I'm getting weird requests from Scooter - a lot of valid urls, but with one or two odd chars appended to the end.
Ie, /faq/account/1f - which is a 404. /faq/account/ is what it should be hitting.
79 requests were 404's from 157 total requests from Scooter. That's not counting the 301's that the apache spelling module redirected. :(
However, big increase in traffic from Scooter.
Sorry, in my theme i get only spam results! Only the worse! All spammers that are allready known and filtered at google, since they can easily be tracked are big winners at alta. (And my theme is not a 100% typical spam theme.)
However, the directory feature (refine search) is really nice. Allthough refining spam results only result in more spam, so ...
New look but same out of date and irrelevant results.
Not sure what relevance these results have to a host:webmasterworld.com search...
Try These Resources
Clothing Men's Shirts • Boots • Skirts
Am I the only one that still gets good referrers from AV? Well I guess of AV continues to improve, we'll need to get a AltaVistaGuy to post here too ;)
yes this would be a great time for a AltaGuy to join in. It would help us in not building rumours or having false conceptions - basically that is what GoogleGuy does.
An AVguy could let us know whether this really is the "updated algo" or just a testing one for example
..or maybe we need an AltaEgoGuy...
keywords in title are important. Keywords in DMOZ title and description are important too.
oh yeah, not really cool!
too much advertsing, a bit better look -
BUT we lost about 75% of our customer-traffic.
The serps are not relevant, no possibility for AV to get in competition with G + F
I hope AV still does some clearing-ups, otherwise we can forget the SE at all.
I wasn't a happy camper until I found this link. [us.altavista.com...]
I *know* where *I* want to go, today. And I don't need a computer to tell me where to go...
|The serps are not relevant, no possibility for AV to get in competition with G + F |
I completely agree with oLeon. Search results are completely irrelevant so in my opinion AV is as good as useless as a search engine. :(
I'm shocked to find my pages are all doing well in the new Alta Vista - almost as well as Google. My pages have been designed only with Google in mind - phrase in titles/H1/H2 and lots of links with good link text - but have not had good keyword density.
This is in contrast to the latest All The Web update (a place where I used to get very good results). My pages there have all but disappeared unless you use the 'exact phrase' checkbox.
So I say, welcome back AV! bye bye All The Web (self-interest beats rational assessment any day)
I'm seeing redirect pages (simple meta refresh) that are top 5 in the SERPs -- but for content that's actually on their TARGET page, and not the listed page itself. However, the target page is also there with its own position in the SERP.
They'd better nail that loophole - you can drive a whole lot of SPAM through it by turning a single #2 listing into 5 top 10 listings through meta refresh pages.
The SERPs look relevant enough to me on a brief check, though still way behind Google and far too cluttered.
To be honest though, after two years of virtual sabbatical (when nobody cared anymore what he was doing) Scooter needs to make some new friends. I see his tyre marks all over one four-year-old site but a site that paid for six months spidering at the start of the year has only two pages in the index. A number of 2-month-old sites which were not submitted to AV or Google but are well linked have never even heard from Scooter; Googlebot was calling round and eating everything in the house within two weeks.
But then the About Basic Submit link gives a 404.
What's the little grey thing down in the corner? A server?
chiyo - or maybe we need an AltaEgoGuy - Too funny! :)
Like I said I have been doing well all along with AV and only see this as an improvement. Checking the logs from one of my sites yesterday, here is my top 4 shown here for illustration:
Yahoo 368 26.04%
MSN 279 19.78%
Google 185 13.13%
Altavista 138 9.81%
This has been fairly consistant and I'm happy with them sending my around %10 of my SE referals and for me, at least on this site, Google doesn't fend that much better. When doing comparison searches I am finding the algo to be holding up pretty well against the competition. However, it is still too early to get the whole story. We'll see how it looks a month from now :)
I can't resolve the site...have we generated them that much traffic?
It looks like they are shrinking the database (ala Inktomi) to include a lot less pages? On some searches Google is showing up to 100x more results.
<<I'm shocked to find my pages are all doing well in the new Alta Vista - almost as well as Google. My pages have been designed only with Google in mind - phrase in titles/H1/H2 and lots of links with good link text - but have not had good keyword density.>>
Same here. A lot of my sites rank very well in AV all of a sudden. But they are buried under the sponsored listings.
They really need to shove those sponsored listings off to the side or whatever. I doubt very much Average Joe is gonna spend much effort to try to locate the real results in this mess. They have miles to go before they will be competitive again.
Ive never had much luck with altavista before and have been on the verge of spending some cash on their express inclusions to get listed with them.
This new update puts all my sites right where I want them.
Three big cheers from this end of Cyberland!
Ok now things look better for different searches on Altavista and there is alot more pages, it looks like the update is finish and it realy looks alot better then 3 days ago.
Keep it up Altavista
P.s the new pages and update has not come to England yet.
They updated two of my sites in the last 24 hours. Picked up changes made just 4 days ago. I like this.
Well done AltaVista, back to the old dumb algo. We had just stared to achieve good listings with natural relevant pages to be replaced with cloaked/doorway pages in alost all areas. So guys, you want positions cast your minds back a couple of years and you wont be far off.
|This new update puts all my sites right where I want them |
It looks like they are using more or less the same old algo that they used a couple of years ago.
Some of our older sites are now right back where they were a long time ago. They have been "gone" for a long time until the last few days...
I cannot see this algo and database lasting long....I've got positions for pages I aint seen in AV for years. I wouldn't put to much hope in keeping the new positions. I got a horrible feeling they'll all change in the next week or so.
I know this is Google forum and this might seem of topic, but... I was just visiting AltaVista. (It used to be my favorite search engine before Google.) I noticed that they changed their look. It has many of the same features as Google does, even it shows "refreshed" listings similar to Google's "fresh".
I also noticed that AltaVista's serps have greatly improved and seem more accurate than Google's since they changed their algo in September.
I am curious if other loyal Googlites find that their eyes wondering to other search engines.
I am visiting alltheweb somewhat and msn more..google is probably still most used but that could change :)
The Altavista revamp looks good to me, very much a Google feel to it.
The SERPS look better than Google's and are definately more consistent. On Altavista I see "cityname widgets" & "cityname statename widgets" producing very similar results, while on Google a totally different set are produced for the two terms. Makes sence the results should be pretty similar to me.
I love the refresh feature AV have added. Odd thing is how my sites seem to be getting "freshed" daily even though I don't pay for the AV PFI / freshing program.;)
Keep up the good work AV.....I would love to see the power shared out more evenly, hopefully this new look will help to get them some of their users back.
With 85% of my SE traffic coming from Google & Partners I would definitely like to see my eggs spread out into a few more baskets. The thought of something nasty happening to the Google Algo makes me very nervous.
>I also noticed that AltaVista's serps have greatly
>improved and seem more accurate than Google's since they
>changed their algo in September.
Yes, we did, not only it does seems to be more accurate than Google, it feels more Google-like than the real Google, I would say. We already mentioned it here, actually.
>The Altavista revamp looks good to me, very much a Google
>feel to it.
True enough. Google may be dying of success, but the Google spirit seems to live on... in other Search Engines!
[edited by: heini at 12:36 pm (utc) on Nov. 15, 2002]
[edit reason] TOS [/edit]
>I love the refresh feature AV have added. Odd thing is how >my sites seem to be getting "freshed" daily even though I >don't pay for the AV PFI / freshing program.
I think that if someone clicks through you your page from a av serp then it gets added to the "fresh" queue for the next 48 hours
percentages , "With 85% of my SE traffic coming from Google & Partners I would definitely like to see my eggs spread out into a few more baskets. The thought of something nasty happening to the Google Algo makes me very nervous"
Im in the same situation I get 89% from Google and friends and makes me very nervous, because I have tried ones where my page got a PR0 and that was not happy times.
After the update my listings are as great as before update, but I think I get a little more hits from Altavista now then before.
Does any of you have the same increase in hits from Altavista, I dont mean huge but just some more hits.
| This 94 message thread spans 4 pages: < < 94 ( 1 2  4 ) > > |